A 3-part series · Part 1 of 3Audit Short StoriesThree short stories on the decisions that shape an audit before fieldwork begins: client acceptance, onboarding and information.
  1. PART 1The Client You Shouldn’t Have AcceptedYou’re reading this
  2. PART 2Why Onboarding Can Determine the Entire AuditRead part 2 →
  3. PART 3The Information Problem Nobody Notices Until Fieldwork StartsRead part 3 →
01

The client looked good on paper

A well-established businessA reputable nameA familiar industryAn attractive feeAnd the firm had capacity

It looked like the kind of engagement a firm would want to win. So the usual acceptance process started: gathering information about the prospective client and the relevant checks applicable.

02

But a few things didn’t quite fit

During the conversations, small signals started to appear. Nothing dramatic.

Signal 1Slow informationThe client was slow to provide some of the information the firm needed. When asked about the records: “We’ll get that across once we get started.”
Signal 2An aggressive timelineThe client’s proposed timeline was aggressive. When the partner raised the concern: “We’ve always managed to get it done.”
Signal 3Moving scopeWhat had initially sounded straightforward began to include a few additional expectations.
Signal 4A history of switchingThe client had changed auditors before. There were explanations, and nothing necessarily meant the firm should reject the engagement.
Signal 5Fee pressureThe client expected some additional work to be covered within the original fee. The partner noticed it. The team noticed it. But the thought was: “We’ll sort that out once we have them.”

Nothing that, by itself, would make the firm walk away.

03

Nothing was obviously wrong

That was the difficulty. There wasn’t one enormous red flag. There were several small signals:

A vague answerA delayed responseAn aggressive deadlineA changing expectationA history of changing auditors

None necessarily meant: don’t accept the client. But together, they were worth asking about. Instead, each concern was given an explanation.

“It’s probably fine.”
“We’ll clarify it later.”
“We don’t want to lose the opportunity over something small.”
And gradually, the firm’s question changedShould we accept this client?What do we need to do to win this client?The firm said yes.
04

A few months later

The small things that had seemed manageable before acceptance were now part of the engagement.

Information still took longer than expected.
The team spent more time following up.
Expectations continued to evolve.
The timeline became difficult to maintain.
More senior time was required.

Eventually, someone went back to the conversations from before the engagement was accepted. And that was the uncomfortable part.

Most of the problems weren’t surprises. The firm had seen the signals. They had discussed some of them. They had explained them away.

The firm’s judgement had been the issue. It had seen enough to ask whether the client was the right fit, but the desire to win the engagement had made that question easier to postpone.

05

Before saying yes

It may be worth asking0 of 5 checked

Tap each one you can answer with confidence.

  • Are they responsive enough for the way we need to work?
  • Are expectations around scope and timing genuinely aligned?
  • How much partner and manager involvement might this engagement require?
  • Does the client fit our delivery model and current capacity?
  • Are we explaining away signals because we want the engagement?
Because sometimes the problem isn’t that the warning signs weren’t visible. It’s that you saw them, discussed them, and chose to explain them away.
Get Started

Schedule Your Personalised Consultation

Talk to our team about offshore audit and finance support for your firm.