A 3-part series · Part 2 of 3Audit Short StoriesThree short stories on the decisions that shape an audit before fieldwork begins: client acceptance, onboarding and information.
  1. PART 1The Client You Shouldn’t Have AcceptedRead part 1 →
  2. PART 2Why Onboarding Can Determine the Entire AuditYou’re reading this
  3. PART 3The Information Problem Nobody Notices Until Fieldwork StartsRead part 3 →
01

Everything looked set

The client had been acceptedThe engagement letter was signedThe kickoff meeting went well

Everyone seemed clear on what needed to be delivered and when. So, the audit team got started.

02

The first questions

A few days in, the first question came up. The audit team sent it to the client contact who attended the kickoff.

Audit teamWe have a question on this one. Can you help?
ClientThat’s something our finance team normally handles directly with the audit manager.
The manager hadn’t expected that. So, the question was redirected.
Audit teamAnother issue has come up. Can you take a look?
ClientThat has to be checked with the AP team.
When the next issue came up, the audit team wasn’t sure who to send it to.
Inside the audit teamWho is actually coordinating these requests?

There wasn’t a clear answer. It wasn’t a major problem. The team figured it out.

03

Different expectations

Then another small concern was raised. A schedule was expected on Tuesday. The client assumed Wednesday was fine. The audit team had planned work around receiving it Tuesday. Again, nobody had done anything unreasonable. They simply had different expectations.

As the audit progressed, the small differences started to accumulate.

The client

  • Expected questions to be consolidated before being sent
  • Assumed the manager would review certain matters
  • Assumed Wednesday was fine for the schedule
The audit team

  • Preferred raising questions as they arose
  • Expected the senior to handle those matters
  • Had planned work around receiving it Tuesday

Some issues were escalated immediately. Others were held back. One person thought a task had been completed. Another thought they were still waiting for it.

Nothing was serious enough to call a problem. But the audit was becoming harder to coordinate. People were spending time asking:

Who is handling this?Who should we send this to?Was this already discussed?When are we supposed to receive this?Who makes the final call?
Then the first deadline was missedBoth sides had been working from different assumptions about how the engagement would operate.Not by much. And there wasn’t one obvious cause. Those assumptions had never really been discussed.
04

What the kickoff covered, and what it missed

The kickoff covered

  • The scope
  • The timeline
  • The key contacts
  • The audit objectives
But it hadn’t really answered

  • How will the work actually move between us?
  • Who owns each type of request?
  • How should questions be raised?
  • What turnaround is expected?
  • When should something be escalated?
  • Who has authority to resolve an issue?
  • What happens when the original plan changes?

Those things had been left to be figured out along the way. And the team was now figuring them out during the audit. That was the uncomfortable realisation.

The onboarding had failed because it had been treated as an introduction rather than as the setup of the working relationship.

05

Every unclear assumption had a cost

Once the audit was underway:

A question took longer.
A task moved between people.
A review point needed another conversation.
A deadline slipped.

Small friction became operational effort.

The real purpose of onboarding isn’t simplyDoes everyone understand the engagement?Does everyone understand how we are going to work together?
06

Before the first testing begins

Make a few things explicit0 of 6 checked

Tap each one you can answer with confidence.

  • Who owns what?
  • How do information and work move between the teams?
  • What turnaround should each side expect?
  • Where should questions go?
  • What needs to be escalated, and to whom?
  • Who makes decisions when something changes?
The audit doesn’t operate according to what was assumed at kickoff. It operates according to what people actually understand and follow. A good onboarding doesn’t just start the audit. It sets up the way the audit will run.
Get Started

Schedule Your Personalised Consultation

Talk to our team about offshore audit and finance support for your firm.