A 3-part series · Part 3 of 3Audit Short StoriesThree short stories on the decisions that shape an audit before fieldwork begins: client acceptance, onboarding and information.
  1. PART 1The Client You Shouldn’t Have AcceptedRead part 1 →
  2. PART 2Why Onboarding Can Determine the Entire AuditRead part 2 →
  3. PART 3The Information Problem Nobody Notices Until Fieldwork StartsYou’re reading this
01

Ready to begin

The PBC list had been sentThe client had responded quicklyThe requested reports were uploadedNothing significant appeared outstanding

The team felt good about the start.

02

One item didn’t quite make sense

One of the first procedures involved testing revenue. The team received the client’s revenue report and began selecting items for testing. The report looked familiar. The numbers looked reasonable. So the work continued.

Revenue reportTraced to records
First itemThe amount was there, but it didn’t tie
Second itemSame issue

So they went back to the client.

Audit teamCan you help us understand how this report was generated?
ClientIt comes from our system, but some transactions are manually adjusted before the report is finalised.
That wasn’t immediately obvious from the report itself.
Audit teamAre all revenue transactions included in this population?
ClientNot exactly. A few categories are excluded and dealt with separately.
Now the team had a different problemThe report was wrong.The report wasn’t necessarily wrong. But it wasn’t quite the population the team had assumed it was.
03

Back to the audit plan

The procedure had been designed around the assumption that the report represented the complete population. Now they had to understand:

What was includedWhat was excludedWhy it was excludedWhat had been manually adjustedHow the report reconciled to the financial statementsWhether another source was needed

A procedure that looked straightforward suddenly required more work.

The team went back to the client again.
Another explanation was provided.
Another reconciliation was requested.
Another piece of information appeared.
04

Nobody withheld anything

None of this was caused by the client withholding information. In fact, the client had provided exactly what the audit team had requested. That was what made the issue easy to miss.

The problem wasn’t

  • “We didn’t receive the information.”
The problem was

  • “We hadn’t understood the information before deciding how we were going to use it.”

The report had a name. It had a date. It had numbers. It looked complete. But the team hadn’t initially asked:

What exactly does this population represent?

And that question mattered. Because an audit procedure can be perfectly designed for the wrong population.

05

The real cost

The team eventually resolved the issue. But the cost was more than the additional questions.

Cost 1Testing reconsideredThe original testing had to be reconsidered.
Cost 2Work redoneSome work had to be redone.
Cost 3More client timeThe client had to spend additional time explaining the report.
Cost 4Time lost elsewhereThe audit team lost time that had been planned for other areas.

Receiving information is not the same as understanding information. A PBC list can be fully cleared while important questions remain unanswered.

06

Before relying on client-generated information

The team may need to understand0 of 6 checked

Tap each one you can answer with confidence.

  • What exactly does this report represent?
  • Where did it come from?
  • How was it generated?
  • Is anything manually changed or excluded?
  • Does it reconcile to another reliable source?
  • Is it actually appropriate for the procedure we intend to perform?
The question shouldn’t simply beDid the client send us the report?Do we understand what this report is telling us, and why we can use it for this purpose?
The information was there. The understanding wasn’t. And sometimes, that’s the information problem that only becomes visible once fieldwork has already started.
Get Started

Schedule Your Personalised Consultation

Talk to our team about offshore audit and finance support for your firm.